Is Pecan Pie A Pie?

Is pecan pie a pie? This is one question that many people are uncertain about. Pecans are one of the major ingredients that make up pecan pie, some believe that this makes it a pie, while others believe that the pastry crust is what defines it as one.

So is pecan pie a pie? Pecan pie is most certainly a pie. This is because of two reasons: first, pecan pie has a pastry crust, which all real pies have. Second, the main ingredient in most pies is fruit or vegetables of some kind. 

So on this belated thanksgiving, be grateful for all the pies you have been blessed with and for those who invented them.

Pecan Pie – A Pie

Pecan pie is a slice of pie, usually eaten as an individual serving. It is made with eggs and pecans, which are baked in a pie crust.

The ingredients give it a high nutritional content but also raise the caloric value substantially.

Although it may be referred to as pecan pie, the nuts used are the difference between this type of pie and other pies.

In other words, pecan pie is a type of pie that contains more than one layer of pastry and also more than one filling.

In the United States, pecan pie is considered to be a favorite holiday treat, especially around Thanksgiving and Christmas.

This popular American dessert includes an outer crust made from flour and either shortening or butter. The filling consists of eggs, syrup, pecans, corn syrup, sugar, vanilla extract, and salt.

What Type Of Pie Is Pecan Pie?

Pecan pie is classified as a type of custard pie, which is a class of pies that have a filling made with milk or cream mixed with eggs.

Custard pies are most often associated with French cuisine but can be found in most cuisines around the world.

Here are other types of pies:

  • Double-Crust Fruit Pie – these pies have a top and bottom crust.
  • Single-Crust Pie – these pies usually have a filling that can be eaten from a bowl with a spoon because pastry does not cover the bottom.
  • Cream pie –  these pies are filled with creamy custard or whipped cream.
  • Meringue Pie – these pies are topped with meringue that is either baked or cooked.
  • Tart – these pies have a crust made with crushed cookies, crackers, or pastry dough.

No matter what type of pie you enjoy, knowing the definition of a pie will help you identify what type of pie you have.

Why Is It Called Pecan Pie?

It is called a pecan pie because of where it comes from. It is a pie that was created in the Southern United States from native trees called pecan trees.

Pecan pie was first invented by Native Americans and settlers in the southern parts of the United States and is most commonly associated with southern cooking.

Pecans are a type of native nut that grows on trees called pecan trees.

So, with this being said, pecan pie was originally created from the nuts from the pecan tree and has been modernized with different ingredients to make it what it is today.

Today, you can find many different variations of this pie, including pumpkin pecan pie which is made with pumpkin puree instead of regular milk.

What Does Pecan Pie Taste Like?

Pecan pie tastes like a mix of marzipan and shortbread, with the nutty taste of roasted pecans. Pecan pies can be served either hot or cold but are traditionally eaten at room temperature.

Some say that the best kind of pecan pie is one that combines a flaky and crumbly crust with a soft, gooey filling.

The pecans should be roasted to bring out their flavor and ground with sugar to make a nutty, caramel-like spread.

That is why Pecan Pie is the official state pie of Texas and Kentucky (and why Pecan Pie Muffins and Pecan Pie Cookies are also popular).

Have you tried one?

I think it’s delicious!

What’s Better, Pecan Pie Or Pumpkin Pie?

I always get this question from my friends, and they always want to know which one is better. Of course, one may like pecan pie more than pumpkin pie and vice versa.

That’s the beauty of Thanksgiving dessert because everyone has different taste buds.

I don’t think there is a specific answer to this question, but if I had to pick between the two, I would say that pumpkin pie is better than the other because pumpkin is healthy and tastes great with spices.

On the other hand, pecan pie is rich in calories, and it’s usually paired with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream to balance the sweetness of this dessert.

To answer this question, I think it’s better to ask the person who is very much interested in what’s better, pecan or pumpkin pie, to come up with his or her own conclusion.

Is Pecan Pie Better Hot Or Cold?

This is another question that has debatable answers.

There are people who just love to eat their pie hot, while others love it better cold.

So is pecan pie better hot or cold?

The answer is that it really depends on personal preference.

People who love their pies hot are passionate about them being served warm.

When they serve something up on a plate, they want to see steam coming off the food – you know, fresh from the oven!

Then there are also people who love their pies cold.

They like to eat them after dinner – maybe with some ice cream on top!

So again, this is something where it really does depend on personal taste!


In conclusion, pecan pie is a pie. Pecan pie is a sweet dessert that’s made with pecans, butter, eggs, vanilla extract, brown sugar, and corn syrup.

Have you tried eating a pecan pie before?

They’re delicious!

Leave a Comment